The Politics Shed- A Free Text Book for all students of Politics.
The Supreme Court has played a crucial role in sanctioning the expansion of the federal government's power, albeit at times reluctantly. A significant decision came as early as 1819 in McCulloch v Maryland, when the court ruled that the 'necessary and proper' clause (although it was not referred to as such) implied the granting to Congress of such powers as were necessary to implement the powers that were explicitly granted. In the particular case, the constitution did not give Congress the power to establish a bank, but the court decided that a bank is an appropriate means of facilitating Congress's power of taxation and spending and, further, that the 'supremacy clause' of Article 6 means that no state has the right to interfere with its operation.
In the twentieth century, the court initially resisted the expansion of congressional power through the New Deal and, in a series of cases, struck down programmes such as the Agriculture Adjustment Act in United States v Butler (1936). However, it eventually gave way in a further series of cases, beginning with West Coast Hotel v Parrish, decided in 1937. Having conceded the right of Congress to manage the national economy and to impose such measures as it saw fit on the states, the court then took the lead itself after the Second World War in limiting the right of the states to regulate the civil liberties of their own citizens, most famously in Brown v Board of Education of Topeka (1954).
The New Deal programmes of the 1930s, and the 'war on poverty' and the Great Society programme of the mid-1960s, saw a further expansion of the reach of the federal government. By the 1960s, its role had come to be seen in a positive light; in the minds of many, the state governments had become associated, principally through their attempted frustration of moves to end segregation, with backwardness and repression, and the federal government now represented a positive force, ensuring all citizens had acceptable standards of basic rights and services.
However, this perception quickly changed. From the late 1960s onwards many, especially on the right, came to believe that the expansion of the federal role had gone too far. It had shown itself unable to deal with, or was even part responsible for, the social problems of the late 1960s. Increasing drug use and crime, changing sexual morals, and often violent student and racial unrest, meant for many Americans that society seemed on the point of collapse. 'States' rights' became a conservative cause; the federal government had become too powerful and intrusive, presided over by an out-of-touch and profligate Congress, its programmes implemented by an unwieldy and inefficient bureaucracy, imposing its liberal agenda on the rest of the nation. Suspicion of the malign intent of the federal government became ubiquitous in popular culture, and was still evident in later decades in television programmes such as the X Files. It manifested itself much more seriously in the bombing of the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City in 1995 by Timothy McVeigh and his associates, which left 168 people dead. McVeigh was motivated by hatred of the federal government, particularly its role in the ending of the Waco siege in 1993
These changes in the federal-state relationship are distinguished by different phases through which this relationship has passed: dual federalism, cooperative federalism and new federalism.
'Dual federalism' is the term associated with approximately the first 150 years of the nation's history — from the 1780s to the 1920s. During this era, the state governments exercised most political power. The role of the federal government was limited mainly to matters concerning money, war and peace. In President Washington's day, there were only three federal executive departments — the Department of the Treasury, the Department of War and the Department of State. The relatively minor role played by the federal government can best be seen by listing some of the little-known presidents of this era: James Polk, Millard Fillmore, Ulysses Grant and Chester Arthur. The federal and state governments each guarded their own powers jealously. Morton Grodzins (1966) called this 'layer-cake' -federalism, in which the federal and state governments had distinct areas of responsibility.
The effects of the Wall Street Crash and the Great Depression changed all that. The term 'cooperative federalism' is used to refer to an era, from the 1930s to the 1960s, in which the federal and state governments cooperated to solve the problems facing US society — such as those relating to poverty, health, education, transport and national security. This era coincides with the administrations of four Democrat presidents — Franklin Roosevelt, Harry Truman, John Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson. It was during this era that the role of the federal government increased significantly. New federal executive departments were created to cope with new policy areas: Defense (1949); Health, Education and Welfare (1953); Housing and Urban Development (1965); and Transportation (1966). The federal government administered categorical grants — schemes by which it was able to stipulate how federal tax dollars were used by the states. By the Clinton era, the federal government was giving over $200 billion to the states, over 90% of which went in the form of categorical grants. So by now the federal government was involved in a number of policy areas where previously only the state governments had operated — such as education, transport and welfare. The two levels of Grodzins' cake had become mixed in what he would now describe as 'marble-cake' federalism.
During the final three decades of the twentieth century, however, there was a discernible movement towards decentralisation — what President Nixon called 'new federalism'. This era saw the rise of block grants — money given to states by the federal government to be used at their discretion within broad policy areas. This change in the federal-state relationship coincides with the administrations of four Republican presidents: Richard Nixon, Gerald Ford, Ronald Reagan and George Bush. Ronald Reagan, speaking in his first Inaugural Address in January 1981, had this to say:
It is my intention to curb the size and influence of the Federal establishment and to demand recognition of the distinction between the powers granted to the Federal Government and those reserved to the States or to the people. All of us need to be reminded that the Federal Government did not create the States; the States created the Federal Government.
Even Democrat President Bill Clinton recognised that Americans' view of the federal-state relationship had changed, when he stated in his 1996 State of the Union Address: 'The era of big government is over.'
- First, a perception had grown that the great federal government programmes of FDR's 'New Deal' or Johnson's 'Great Society' had not been as successful as first thought. Too much money had been wasted on bureaucracy
Second, there was a belief that the federal government had simply failed to tackle some pressing social problems, such as gun crime, drugs, abortion, welfare and poverty. As a result, scepticism about the federal government's effectiveness had developed.
- Third, there was a growing distrust of 'Washington politicians'. The Watergate affair and the debacle in Vietnam both lowered trust in the federal government. Between 1976 and 2000, America elected five presidents — four were former state governors, while only one, George Bush (1988), was a Washington politician. The unsuccessful movement to impose term limits on members of Congress, which became very vocal in the early 1990s, was a manifestation of this distrust of Washington politics.
- Fourth, decisions by the mainly Republican-appointed Supreme Court began to limit the scope of federal government power. New federalism' was strongly associated with the Republican Party.
Finally, the frequent election of Republican presidents during this era, the election of a Republican-controlled Congress in 1994 and the election of Republican state governors allowed the party to put its policies into effect.
Bloc Party Federalism is a political theory coined by legal scholar Michael S. Greve that describes how intense national political polarization has transformed the relationship between the federal government and U.S. states. [1, 2, 3]
Rather than viewing federalism through traditional constitutional lenses—where states operate as independent, sovereign entities checking the federal government—this concept argues that states now act as unified "red" or "blue" coalitions (blocs) to advance or resist highly partisan national agendas. [1, 2]
Under this model, federalism is no longer a tool to protect local diversity or general states' rights; it is a mechanism used by national political parties to project power and maintain their respective coalitions. [1, 2]
Core Characteristics of Bloc Party Federalism
1. States as Direct Partisan Agents
In the past, state governments might conflict with Washington over institutional authority or local economic interests, regardless of party. Under Bloc Party Federalism, state actions are dictated by national party lines. [1, 2]
Red Blocs: Republican-led states coordinate with each other and with conservative federal actors to swiftly implement shared policies or block federal regulations. [1, 2]
Blue Blocs: Democratic-led states orchestrate coordinated resistance (such as multi-state lawsuits or sanctuary policies) against conservative federal mandates. [1, 2]
2. The Breakdown of "Cooperative Federalism"
For decades, American federalism relied on a "cooperative" framework where federal agencies worked harmoniously with state bureaucrats to implement national programs like Medicaid, environmental protections, and transport funding. Bloc Party Federalism breaks this down. When a federal agency issues a major mandate, an entire bloc of states will explicitly refuse cooperation, use administrative waivers to alter the policy, or immediately sue the federal government to freeze the action. [1, 2, 3]
3. Strategic Realignment of Ideology
Because federalism has been weaponised by these blocs, both parties have flipped their traditional views on states' rights depending on who controls the White House: [1]
Democrats, traditionally the champions of a strong national government, aggressively invoke federalist principles, "anti-commandeering" laws, and state sovereignty to insulate themselves from conservative federal policies. [1]
Republicans, traditionally the champions of limited central government and local devolution, readily embrace maximalist federal powers to impose uniform national rules or override progressive local laws. [1, 2]
4. The Administrative & Judicial Battlefield
Because Congress is frequently gridlocked, the conflict between these state blocs plays out almost entirely through executive actions and the legal system. High-level political officials in the White House act in close concert with friendly state governors, while opposition state Attorneys General form multi-state coalitions to clog the federal courts with lawsuits. The legal battles are not genuinely about how much power a state should have, but rather which party's policy will prevail. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Dual Federalism (1789–1930s): The 'Layer Cake'
For the first 140 years of the nation, the United States operated under a system of Dual Federalism. Under this model, the federal government and state governments functioned within strictly defined, mutually exclusive jurisdictions.
Federal Focus: Confined strictly to constitutionally enumerated powers, such as national defense, foreign policy, coining money, and managing tariffs.
State Focus: Exercised "police powers" over everyday life, including education, internal trade, civil law, and public health.
The Metaphor: A layer cake, where the layers are distinct and never mix. The Supreme Court largely acted as a referee, ensuring neither layer encroached upon the other.
2. Cooperative Federalism (1930s–1960s): The 'Marble Cake'
The catastrophic economic collapse of the Great Depression exposed the limits of state capabilities, forcing a fundamental realignment under President Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal. Cooperative Federalism emerged to address national crises through joint intergovernmental action.
The Strategy: The federal government began using its massive taxing power to fund large-scale social welfare programs, public works projects, and infrastructure.
Grants-in-Aid: Washington provided states with funding (categorical grants), but attached specific federal strings and guidelines on how that money must be spent.
The Metaphor: A marble cake, where national, state, and local policies are swirled together, making lines of authority blurry and interdependent.
3. Creative Federalism (1960s–1970s): The Rise of Federal Dominance
Under President Lyndon B. Johnson’s Great Society initiative, the balance of power tilted heavily toward Washington. Creative Federalism bypassed state governments entirely in many instances.
Direct-to-Local Funding: The federal government started providing grants directly to city governments, community groups, and local districts to combat poverty and racial inequality.
Unfunded Mandates: Washington increasingly ordered states to meet national environmental, civil rights, and educational standards without providing the necessary funds to implement them, penalising states that did not comply.
4. New Federalism (1970s–1990s): Devolution
In reaction to decades of growing federal authority, Presidents Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan championed New Federalism, a movement centered on devolution—the systematic transfer of power back to the states.
Block Grants: The federal government consolidated narrow categorical grants into broad "block grants." These gave states massive lumps of money with minimal federal conditions, allowing local governors to decide how best to address local issues.
Welfare Reform: The peak of this era occurred in 1996, when the federal government ended traditional federal welfare entitlements and turned the administration of aid over to the states.
5. Modern Federalism (2000s–Present): Partisan Federalism
Today, federalism operates as a flexible, often contentious tool of national politics. It is characterised by a hyper-polarized environment where states and Washington alternate roles based on party alignment.
Federal Preemption: The national government frequently steps in to establish sweeping uniform standards across all states (such as national educational targets or healthcare regulations).
State-Led Resistance: When a political party is out of power in Washington, its state governors and attorneys general use state legislation, sanctuary laws, and multi-state lawsuits to block or nullify federal directives.